šŸ™„ Seriously, YouTube?

Ads aren't more effective; the "skip" button is smaller and more translucent

Presented by

Culture, tech, travel, business + marketing in 5 min. or less

We may earn commissions if you buy from any affiliate links

Aman Group will launch a new brand, Janu, with a new 122 key hotel in Tokyoā€™s Azabudai Hills development. Expect 8 restaurants, 2 boutiques, and one of the largest wellness centers in Tokyo (Janu Hotels / Travel + Leisure)

šŸ”¼ Gold ā€”and Bitcoin. The precious metal is at an all time high, while the cryptocurrency is worth more than it has been in 20 months Ā»Ā»

šŸ”½ Spotifyā€™s headcount. However, shares went up after the CEO sent a memo saying theyā€™ll cut 17% of staff Ā»Ā»Ā Related: Klarna froze hiring because AI can do many jobs instead Ā»Ā»

šŸ’¬Ā ā€œIā€™m a high street girl at heart.ā€ Suki Waterhouseā€™s Fashion Awards dress is from H&M and costs less than Ā£300 Ā»Ā»

šŸ›« Tokyo's most-anticipated luxury hotel has an opening date, and it's accepting reservations now Ā»Ā»

šŸ‘— Valentino and Sam Smith were lauded at the Fashion Awards in London Ā»Ā»

šŸ’Ž Cash-rich tenants from Ukraine, China and the US are ditching their traditional stomping grounds (Belgravia, Mayfair) in favor of the leafier surroundings of St Johnā€™s Wood. Demand for multi-million-pound homes in Northwest London is heating up Ā»Ā»Ā More: Demand for Londonā€™s Ā£20,000 a month rentals has boomed Ā»Ā»

Valenciaā€™s Central Market. The Spanish city was recently named one of the best for expats (Juan Gomez / Unsplash)

Americaā€™s declining malls are becoming lifestyle hubs Ā»Ā»

Parisā€™s 85 (yes, 85) best hotels Ā»Ā»

A company can only be as agile as its least flexible team. Hereā€™s how to create a ā€œculture of agilityā€ Ā»Ā»

The top three best global cities for expats are in Spain: Malaga, Alicante and Valencia Ā»Ā»

Rosewood assumed management of three renowned New Zealand resorts Ā»Ā»

Americaā€™s best non-alcoholic beers (that actually taste good) Ā»Ā»

After being pushed to next year, Googleā€™s forthcoming multimodal AI system Gemini is now coming a bit sooner than expected Ā»Ā»

London's hottest restaurants for December Ā»Ā»

A new app call Dubbing AI now allows anyone to talk in anyone else's voice, anytime, anywhere Ā»Ā»

ā€œI worked at a popular hotel chain for 3 years. From lost-and-found rules to freebies, here's what would surprise guestsā€Ā Ā»Ā»Ā 

Harry Stylesā€™ Pleasing brand now sells scented candles Ā»Ā»

Six London streets have been named the best to live on in the UK Ā»Ā»

This US airline is going viral for its secret trading cards, though theyā€™ve been around for 20 years. Here's how to get one Ā»Ā»

D-IDā€™s Creative Realityā„¢ studio app heralds a new era of AI videos. Users can now create customized digital humans that look, sound, and speak like real peopleā€” right from their phone Ā»Ā»

Attention New Yorkers: thereā€™s a new permanent bike boulevard in Williamsburg Ā»Ā»

68,000 gallons of fake, inedible ā€˜olive oilā€™ seized in Spain, and 11 have been arrested Ā»Ā»

When used properly, a proper CRM software is a stress melter for small businesses. Give Less Annoying CRM a try. fate v/ future readers get 60 days free, v/ the usual 30 Ā»Ā»

YouTube ads arenā€™t more effective; the ā€œskipā€ buttonā€™s just smaller and harder to press. Hereā€™s what that means for influencers

Is YouTubeā€™s advertising team running out of ideas in the face of the rise of influencer marketing?

SKIP

YouTube made its ā€œskip adā€ button smaller. Again.

The new look skip button seems designed to fool YouTube video viewers into accidentally tapping through to the ad instead of skipping it. (The buttonā€™s also more translucent than the previous design.)

UM

This design change raises several significant issues in our view:

It feels like a worse user experience. YouTube, like every platform, is here to keep users engaged/satisfied.

Making it more difficult than ever to skip ads because of a smaller and less visible button, sounds frustrating ā€”not just because of the inconvenience, but also because feeling tricked into engaging with an ad unintentionally is irritating.

Inaccurate or misinterpreted ad performance. For advertisers, accurate engagement data is critical. If this lilā€™ button change means more accidental clicks, advertisers are going to see a (misleading) boost in their ad performance metrics. This superficial increase would obviously not be a signal of greater/genuine interest, nor more engagement from potential customers. This, in turn, would lead to skewed marketing data, and potentially misguided strategic decisions. (And online advertising is full of enough bots and online fraud as it is.)

Trust issues. Both users and advertisers rely on a level of trust with the platform. Users trust that they can control their viewing experience, and advertisers trust in the accuracy of the data they receive. Manipulating the ad-skipping feature could be seen as a breach of this trust, potentially harming YouTube's reputation with both users and advertisers.

Long term implications/user churn. If design changes like this one lead to a decrease in user satisfaction, that could mean bad news for YouTube. Annoyed users might simply visit less often. There are no shortage of other platforms for content. Equally important: advertisers might start questioning the efficacy of their ad spend on YouTube.

INFLUENCERS HAVE ENTERED THE CHAT

What makes this whole button thing interesting, in our view, is that it coincides with the increased professionalization of a newer ā€”and perhaps betterā€” type of advertising: influencer marketing.

A recent newsletter from Devin Reed, an accomplished B2B SaaS influencer, and the head of content at a sales software firm, caught my eye.

Devin observes that many B2B companies choose influencers for marketing deals based exclusively on their follower counts.

Thatā€™s a mistake.

Choosing influencers based on follower count is a rookie move because, as Devin puts it, being popular and being influential are NOT the same thing ā€”and that's without getting ā€œinto click farms, engagement pods, or the fact that most ā€œinfluencersā€ that regularly get 500+ reactions on their post canā€™t get 15 people to show up to an actual event, let alone buy anythingā€¦ā€

What Devin is looking for from influencers in his role as head of content is is the ability to build trust at scale. What that means is he's looking for influencers ā€œwho are respected, credible, and most importantly, can create a new conversation or sway an existing one with people I want to sell to.ā€

In other words, someone who has real influence. Someone who can motivate action through ā€” you guessed it ā€” trust. Maybe they have 5,000 followers. Maybe 90,000. That affects the price tag, but doesnā€™t qualify them in or out of my strategy.

OK, WHATā€™S THE POINT HERE?

Devin thinks that B2B influencer marketing is going to evolve from simple paid LinkedIn posts, into bigger brand deals, not unlike the NIL deals (name, image, likeness) deals that exist in big time American college sports. That means signing top-shelf influencers with non-compete contracts, just like shoe companies do for top athletes.

Ultimately, advertising is about trust.

But that trust needs to flow in all directions: consumers need to trust the messages they're being delivered, however advertisers also need to trust the platforms they are paying to display those messages.

Look for 2024 to bring more serious and robust influencer marketing deals between brands and trustworthy people of influence to the marketing landscape.

YouTubeā€™s playing a silly game with this Skip Ads button redesign.

If their ad stats inch upwards thanks to a smaller and more translucent button, that doesn't feel like more trust. It just feels annoying.

And adland has plenty of that already.

More:

How Devin Reed is going to structure B2B Influencer deals Ā»Ā»

YouTube just made it harder to avoid ads with a tiny skip button Ā»Ā»

Written by Jon Kallus. Thanks for reading.

How eCommerce Brands Unlock Profitable Growth

Still not hitting those ideal numbers for your eCommerce brand?

Multiple brands have soared in recent weeks because they have a secret weapon: Shoelace, a Shopify-recommended digital ad agency.

Just look at these results:

  • One skincare brand saw a 316% revenue jump in just 3 weeks.

  • A fashion powerhouse doubled orders in 2 weeks.Ā 

  • A home decor brand saw a 240% ROAS spike in just 2 weeks.

Shoelace delivers results, not just promises. They aim for profitable, sustainable growth.

Want to be the next success story?

Work with Shoelace this Q4 and knock 15% off your first month.

Join the conversation

or to participate.